This week saw the publication of the final Milburn review into young people who are NEET (not in education, employment or training). As the mum of a 19-year-old PDAer who is NEET, I have a lot of thoughts on this! So this post is about anxiety, qualifications, Functional Skills and work - and what the review could mean for young people like ours.
![]() |
| Photo by pie apple on Unsplash |
But first, a trip (well, two) to the cinema…
Two trips to the cinema in one week?!
Last week, I went to the cinema twice. That's probably doubled my attendance this year! And it was to see the same film both times.
Our PDAer rarely watches films or TV at home. It's mostly YouTube clips, and generally she likes to repeat-view the same sketch multiple times. She doesn't usually like anything with real people in it (although she made an exception for the Trapped kids' TV series that she created an animation about last month!).
We've only seen a handful of films at the cinema (and some we've had to leave early): Inside Out, Home, Trolls and a few others. She's very specific about what she will and won't watch!
The film we went to see this time, Forgotten Island, came out last month. But she'd only just heard about it last week, and thankfully it was still showing at the cinema, so off we went. She loved it so much that she wanted to go back and see it again, but with her dad as well as me – so off we went again!
The film itself was brilliant, and I highly recommend it. Forgotten Island is an animated adventure comedy from DreamWorks. It follows Jo and Raissa, who have been best friends since childhood but are about to go their separate ways after high school. On their last night together they find a mysterious portal that takes them to a fantastical island, but the catch is that their only way out might cost them the memories of their whole friendship.
This one pulled on my heartstrings heavily ðŸ˜
I have more thoughts about the friendship aspect of this film, and they might be in an upcoming blog post, but what I want to focus on today is anxiety.
The anxiety nobody sees
An aspect of our life that I don't think many people (outside of the PDA community) understand is the extremely high level of anxiety our girl lives with every day. The photo above shows her 'mood octopus' - a very important item in her life; it's reversible with a smile on the other side and she uses it to show her emotions. This is anxiety rather than anger, for her. (I've linked this item in my post titled 30 Unique Gift Ideas for Children & Teens Who Are Hard to Buy For (Autism and ADHD edition))
This was supposed to be a fun trip. It was her suggestion, to go and see a film she really wanted to see. And still, she found it so difficult to leave the house.
Part of her anxiety is around travelling. (This was contested, or simply not believed, when we went to tribunal - which was extremely irritating, to put it mildly.) The trouble is that nobody else sees this anxiety, because she can't travel with anyone other than us.
Being in a car makes her feel sick. She wears travel sickness bands to try to combat that, and we often travel with the windows down, even when it's freezing and blowing a gale! We have at times managed trips that are slightly further away, but more distance and more time travelling means more anxiety. This is more than just feeling car sickness.
There's anxiety about public transport too, and most of that comes from having to be with other people. People are a great source of anxiety for her. She doesn't like faces, or the whole unpredictability aspect of being out in society, where somebody might ask her a question and she doesn't know how to respond.
There are other parts of public transport she struggles with. When we've been on a train, she worries intensely about leaving something behind, or losing or dropping her things. We did fly when she was younger, but at some point (around the age of 10) her anxiety about flying became too great. Now she won't fly anywhere.
So getting in the car to go to the cinema, which might be such an easy thing for many young people her age, is not an easy thing for her. Last week, I saw that twice.
Her anxiety shows up as physical sickness symptoms. It also lowers her self-esteem, because she doesn't believe she can do it. She doesn't know how she's going to do it. There's a long, long build-up, and we never know whether we're actually going to be able to leave the house.
What I have to do is use all the PDA approaches I know, and try to stay calm. I give the message once, simply: it doesn't matter if we're not able to leave the house. Then I try to calm her nerves with as few words as possible, and wait to see if she can manage it.
All this, for an activity that's supposed to be fun.
So when it comes to work...
Our girl is 19, and she would be classed as NEET. She's not working because she can't work in typical work environments.
The only qualifications she has are Functional Skills English at Level 2 (which is equivalent to a pass at GCSE), Functional Skills maths at Level 1 (which, as I understand it, is not quite GCSE level), and a GCSE-equivalent award in art.
She missed an awful lot of education through not having the right setting, and I've written about that in previous posts - most recently in the post-16 section of School Attendance and Unauthorised Absence. The specialist school she went to did help her gain those qualifications - but she was only with them for up to six hours a week, over a period of 18 months. Had she been allowed to attend for more hours, she may well have passed more.
Once she'd finished at the specialist school, at the age of 18 (I'd asked for her to stay until 19 but was told that wasn't possible), she tried an entry level art course at mainstream college. Their focus was to get her studying to pass English and maths GCSEs. For a PDAer, the demand of having to do that was too great, and it caused extra anxiety and ultimately a breakdown leading to non-attendance.
And being in a mainstream college, around peers she could clearly see were coping with the environment when she wasn't, was really difficult - and damaging - for her.
The thing is, I think her language skills are far beyond many of her peers. My guess is that she would actually do really well in GCSE English - but she's not able to access that exam in any way.
If you read her fiction writing, you'd see it straight away: her vocabulary, her understanding of grammar, and her general understanding of the world around her and issues such as politics and science are all extremely high. But that doesn't translate into qualifications.
She would like to work. And she knows exactly what she'd like to do: create a kids' TV series! The first stage of that would be working on animation projects.
Because typical work environments, and society in general, are so hard for her for so many reasons (sensory issues included), she's more likely to do well working from home, or in a very small work environment. She is not now, and maybe not ever, going to be able to work in places where there are lots of people, and where she's given demands to action tasks within certain time scales.
Even something like stacking shelves in Sainsbury's would be too much for her to cope with. As well as human interaction, she also struggles around animals, so working with animals isn't an option either.
I honestly don't know what else somebody could suggest.
We know what would be a good future for her. But opportunities for that are hard to find. (If anyone knows someone who works in the animation industry and has good advice for us on which software or hardware is best for her to use, we'd be very grateful if you send us a message!)
I'm not sure qualifications matter so much for the kind of work she wants to do, because all her skills so far are self-taught. I'm sure she could handle any aspect of learning new animation software and hardware. What she can't currently do is access further education courses where she has to learn to a prescribed curriculum.
So qualifications are part of the challenge, and social interactions are the other part.
Why don't more parents know about Functional Skills?
Functional Skills exams are something that not all parents know about. They're practical, applied qualifications in English and maths (and as I mentioned above, Level 2 is the equivalent of a pass at GCSE).
But they're not easy to access. I think they should be available through all schools, mainstream and specialist, and for children who need to be home educated too.
There's a parent-led campaign called Fairer Exams with a petition I'd love you to sign. It's asking for fairer exams and fairer futures - and specifically, for an applied pathway within GCSE English and maths, like Functional Skills. Students would still come out with a GCSE qualification.
According to the petition, over 200,000 young people each year leave school without a grade 4 pass in GCSE English and maths. It also points out that many of them later pass Functional Skills, which shows they have the skills - it's the assessment format they struggle with.
And anybody who wants to go back into education is forced to resit these exams. Which is pretty pointless, when the exam format just isn't accessible for so many.
You can sign the petition here - it only takes a minute!
But exams are only one part of the picture. Understanding the individual matters just as much - and that's been on my mind a lot this week.
Dream centres… or understanding centres?
I saw a reel on Instagram recently of Simon Squibb meeting the Prime Minister, and telling him that the school system is broken. (You can watch it here.) One of his suggestions was that job centres should be renamed "dream centres".
It sounds like a nice idea – and so much more hopeful than a job centre! But what we really need is for the people working in those dream centres to understand that, for some young people, it's can't, not won't. (I've written before about can't, not won't when it comes to school refusal - you can read that post here.) They are not choosing not to work because they are lazy. It's that they can't work, because they need a different environment from typical workplaces, and they need more support to access society. Understanding the individual and their challenges is key.
What is the Milburn review?
All of this feels very timely, because this week saw the publication of the final Milburn review into young people who are NEET. That's nearly one million young people – one in eight – and the review says more than seven in ten of them want to be in work, education or training.
And among disabled young people who are NEET, the review reports autism for 22.7% of them, and depression and anxiety for 23.8%. So this really is about young people like ours.
From what I understand so far, there's a lot in it. Some of it sounds vaguely positive: new legal guarantees of support, mental health help without having to wait for a diagnosis, and Disability Living Allowance continuing until 18 rather than stopping at 16. There would be a new Youth Opportunity Service too, and the report says "The young person can meet with a named adviser within 14 days of entering the service." It even talks about shaping roles around what disabled young people can contribute.
I do have concerns about these named advisers, though. The adviser has to be somebody who is not pushing for young people to be in work at any cost.
And for our girl, an adviser would need to agree to speak to me. She isn't able to communicate easily with others, and as her parent, I'm the one who understands her the most. I can already see her being signed off a service, or not having access to an adviser at all, because she's unable to attend appointments at a centre, for example.
To be fair, the review does say young people should be able to reach the new service online, or through an organisation they already know and trust, as well as in person. I really hope that happens in practice! But also what happens when they are no longer involved with any organisation? When their parent/carer is all that they have?
There are also big proposed changes to benefits, including a new Youth Allowance for under-25s replacing the health element of Universal Credit, and a new Additional Cost Allowance to replace PIP. And the report says young people with anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism "would be both expected and enabled to be in work".
Our girl is likely to need benefits, because she can't access typical work environments. I'd love it if someone could help find her work that really suited her abilities and skills - but I don't think we're there yet.
I don't think she should be punished for being a young person who is unable to work. And there's no point expecting her to work, or forcing her to work. It's just not going to work (excuse the pun) - that's the problem.
The review says young people would have a duty to engage - including not refusing reasonable offers without good cause - and that a young person who persistently refuses to engage, after other routes have been tried, should ultimately lose their Youth Allowance (although it also says sanctions should be rare). But who decides what’s ‘reasonable’ for a young person like ours? And for a PDAer, what looks like ‘refusing to engage’ is so often can’t, not won’t.
For a PDAer, expectations and demands are virtually impossible to deal with on a day-to-day basis - so 'enabled' really does have to come first.
Remember the cinema? Even that - a fun trip that she wanted to make, at her own suggestion - caused extreme anxiety. Now imagine the demands of a job interview, or a shift that starts at 9am sharp.
That's the trouble with anxiety: it's so hard for other people to see. A young person can seem verbally or mentally able at a certain level, but in reality be unable to cope. And that gap is exactly where young people like ours fall through the cracks.
It's worth pointing out that the Milburn review is only a set of recommendations for now - the government is due to give a fuller response in the new year. Any changes to benefits would also need new laws first, and would be phased in.
If you'd like to read the Milburn review for yourself, it's all on this page on the GOV.UK website. The executive summary is a good place to start, and there's an Easy Read version too.
So where do I stand?
Whether we're talking about a cinema trip or a job centre, it keeps coming back to the same thing for me: understanding the individual comes first.
I know it's impossible for the government to speak to every single family and understand every individual's experience. But it is important for them to listen to a vast range of challenges in the SEND world.
I'd love for Alan Milburn to come and sit in my house for 20 minutes. I could tell him what life is like for our girl, and why it's not as simple as having an adviser and walking into a workplace - or completing further education, or even GCSE education.
And although I'm backing the Fairer Exams petition, and the idea that Functional Skills exams should be open to all children, I don't think qualifications are the be-all and end-all. No exam results doesn't mean no ability. Actually, it's a person's skills and abilities that should be considered. They should be allowed to show these in a variety of ways, and be offered support to fill the gaps.
Alan, the kettle's on :)
![]() |
| Photo by Mel Poole on Unsplash |
What do you think? Comments are always very much appreciated!
Further reading
- School Attendance and Unauthorised Absence
- Is Autism Overdiagnosed? Are Autism Levels the Answer?
- Top Ten information posts about PDA (Pathological Demand Avoidance)
- The Not Fine in School series
- How to help children with Pathological Demand Avoidance
- My post on can't, not won't and school refusal
- The PDA Society - always the first place I send other families
If you'd like to make sure you never miss a new blog post, you can sign up to my Substack newsletter here - it's free, and you'll get a notification every time something new goes up :)





No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are always very much appreciated and can really help the conversation go further...